Skip to content
[topbar_item icon="phone" text="1-800-987-654" link="tel:1-800-987-654"/][topbar_item icon="envelope" text="admin@example.com" link="mailto:admin@example.com"/][topbar_item type="login" icon="user" icon_logged_in="sign-out" text="User Login" text_logged_in="Log Out" logout_text="Logout"/]

But financing it is hard.

There is no magic to the construction part of affordable housing.  Housing does not get cheaper to build by calling it ‘affordable’ or filling it with lower-income folks.  There is, for instance, no reason why affordable housing should be materially different on the inside or the outside from regular market housing.  Sure, there will be some differences, and even more from ‘high end’ or ‘luxury’ accommodation, but the primary costs of construction are the same no matter what.  Finishes are not a material cost of construction, at least for distinguishing affordable from regular market rentals .  As a result, the only thing that a builder can change that makes a significant difference to unit costs is the size of the units, which of course runs smack into the need for large units such as 3 bedroom flats for the many households who need larger affordable homes.

The only difference is financing.

What distinguishes affordable housing from market housing is financing, or more precisely, ‘does the occupant pay all of the costs of use, or does someone else provide financing for their housing”.

That’s it.  That is the only real difference between affordable rentals and market rentals.  There is no other distinction that matters.

Financing options

One option is, with CMHC’s MLI Select, to lower the cost of capital or at least the cashflow requirements for mixed use projects such that the developer is incented to set aside some units (at least 10% for MLI Select) as affordable. 

In other words, by tailoring the loan guarantees of the MLI Select program, especially by allowing amortization periods up to 40 years, CMHC has incented apartment developers to forego some monthly rent (the difference between market and affordable for the affordable units).  Longer amortization periods improve the cashflow of the owner of the building in the early years to offset the lost rent.  The tradeoff is the increased risk of default created by the longer amortization period, and thus the reduced paydown of loan principal especially in the early years.

One way to look at MLI Select is that it is using market rentals to cross subsidize affordable housing.  From an urban planning perspective, the good news is that no one building has only affordable units, and instead they are scattered across many projects.

The other way to think of the MLI Select program is that it uses loan guarantees to offset the increased risk of default.  Presuming that the premiums are properly priced, many developers and thus many tenants pay the risk that a few projects fail. 

MLI Select is probably cheapest way to ‘finance’ affordable housing.  Assuming that it is priced properly, it has the hallmarks of excellent policy.

Other financing options

            Capital grants/low cost loans

One way to reduce the cost of housing for the occupants is for some other entity to bear the upfront or capital costs of construction.  Sometimes this is via ‘low cost mortgages’, sometimes via outright capital grants, and sometimes via reduction or waiver of the fees and costs charged to market buildings. 

For instance, waiver by a municipality of development charges for affordable housing is a form of ‘one time grant, from municipal taxpayers’ which lowers the capital cost of the affordable housing.

Outright grants are hugely expensive, and this limits their scaleability.

Reduced-rate loans are a viable option.  Each 1% per $100,000 of interest reduction provides approximately $100/mo in possible rent reductions.

            Operating grants

Another means to reduce the cost of housing for the occupants is for someone else to help defray some of the costs ‘each month’.  Usually this is in the form of ‘rent subsidies’.  These are ‘operating grants’ usually from government or charities (foundations especially).

Operating grants have the benefit of flexibility, and they can be turned on and off over time.  This is beneficial for the granting parties, but it creates uncertainty for both building owners and occupants.  The degree of uncertainty depends, in large part, on the term of the granting commitment.  Short (annual) granting commitments are far too short to be helpful – housing works on 10-25 year cycles.

Housing grants are expensive and this limits the number of affordable units that can be created.  Of course, this is the fundamental challenge of affordable housing – finding a way to reduce the occupancy cost of tens of thousands of homes will cost, at a minimum, billions of dollars no matter which tool is chosen.  Ultimately we must do three things –

  • Experiment with all possible tools.
  • Be acutely aware of the costs, and where possible try to chose and refine the tools for financing affordable housing so that they are as cost-effective as possible.
  • Be humble about the magnitude of the crisis, and thus the need for sustained effort over a long period of time to address it successfully.  Quick shortcuts and easy wins will not work.
Back To Top